Family Law Newsletter

Filial Consortium Damages in Wrongful Death Actions

Husbands and wives have traditionally been entitled to recover damages for “loss of consortium.” In cases where a spouse is severely injured or killed, the non-injured spouse will typically sue the wrongdoer for her loss of consortium. The resulting damages generally represent her inability to enjoy the same love, affection and companionship that she did prior to her spouse’s injury.

In recent years, many jurisdictions have similarly recognized a parent’s claim for loss of a child’s consortium, or “filial consortium.” Filial consortium damages are intended to compensate the parent for various attributes of the parent-child relationship, including, for example, affection, companionship, solace and care. Although some jurisdictions allow filial consortium damages in cases where the child is severely injured, this article will focus on parents’ wrongful death claims with respect to a deceased child.

Recovery for Wrongful Death of a Child: A Historical Perspective

In the early 20th century, largely based on general principles of English law, wrongful death statutes typically limited damages to economic losses; i.e., those losses that could be objectively measured by a monetary standard. For this reason, when parents sued for the wrongful death of a child, the damages award was limited to the value of the child’s services and earning capacity; e.g., the child’s performance of farm chores or work for wages.

Due to changing societal and economic conditions, the American legal system no longer exclusively values children according to their monetary contributions to the family. Instead, children are valued for their love, affection, companionship and society. As a consequence, modern courts acknowledge that the value of a child’s consortium far exceeds the economic value of the child’s services.

Modern Legal Authority: Loss of Filial Consortium

In wrongful death actions, most jurisdictions permit parents to recover damages for loss of consortium. Although the law varies from state to state, filial consortium damages are usually available pursuant to the state’s wrongful death statute. While some states have set forth explicit statutory language to provide for filial consortium damages, other states permit parents to recover based on judicial interpretation of the statute. The law similarly varies with respect to whether a parent may recover for the loss of an adult child.

Though not exhaustive, the following examples are illustrative of state law regarding filial consortium damages in wrongful death actions:

• Texas allows parents to recover consortium damages in wrongful death cases.
• Oklahoma’s wrongful death statute expressly permits recovery for the “loss of companionship of the children and parents of the decedent.”
• In Tennessee, parents may recover filial consortium damages in wrongful death actions. Tennessee’s statute allows recovery of filial consortium damages as part of the pecuniary value of the decedent’s life.
• Florida’s Wrongful Death Act states, “Each parent of a deceased minor child may…recover for mental pain and suffering from the date of injury [causing death]. Each parent of an adult child may also recover for mental pain and suffering if there are no other survivors.”
• In Kentucky, parents may recover for the loss of affection and companionship of a minor child.
• Illinois permits parents to recover for the loss of society suffered upon the wrongful death of a minor child.

© 2024 NextClient.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

• Modification of Child Custody Agreements
  Generally, a couple who divorces or legally separates must make a determination regarding the physical and legal custody of their children and visitation rights, either by mutual agreement or court order. When an established child... Read more.
• Parental Liability for Acts of Minor Children
  In most states, the age of majority (when a person is recognized by law as an adult), is 18 years of age or older. A “minor” is a person who is under the age of 18. When a minor breaks the law or causes damage or injury to... Read more.
• Separate Return vs. Joint Return for Federal Taxes
  For federal income tax purposes, there are five tax “statuses:” single; head of household; married filing jointly; married filing separately; and qualifying widow(er) with dependent child. Status affects tax credits and... Read more.
• Relief from Community Property Tax Laws
  Under the laws of some states (i.e., “community property” states), property acquired and income earned during marriage may be “community” property. This generally means that such income may be considered income... Read more.

• Scaffolding Collapse in Manhattan Injures Three, Sparks Renewed Calls for Reform
• EdTech Company PowerSchool Target of Lawsuit Over Claims They Illegally Sell Student Data
• MLB Players Union Settles Lawsuit With FanDuel Over Unauthorized Use of Player Likenesses
• Federal Judge Blocks Biden Administration Overtime Rule, Citing Legal Overreach
• Kraft Heinz Faces Class Action Over Alleged False Labeling on Mac & Cheese